Working in environments that require flame-resistant (FR) clothing presents unique challenges, especially when dealing with fluctuating temperatures and diverse work conditions. Simply donning a single FR garment might not always provide the optimal combination of protection and comfort. This is where the art of layering comes into play. By strategically combining multiple FR garments, workers can adapt to various thermal conditions while maintaining crucial arc flash and flash fire protection.
This article will explore the principles behind effectively layering FR clothing, considering different temperature ranges and work environments. We will also highlight key considerations such as moisture management and the critical importance of avoiding non-FR layers underneath. While this article offers general guidance, always refer to specific workplace safety protocols, hazard assessments, and relevant standards like NFPA 70E for electrical safety and OSHA 1910.132 for general PPE requirements.
The Principles of FR Layering
The core principles of layering for thermal comfort also apply to FR clothing, with the added imperative of maintaining FR protection across all layers:
- Moisture Management: The innermost layer should wick away sweat to keep the skin dry. Moisture buildup can lead to discomfort, chilling in cold weather, and even skin irritation. In hot environments, efficient moisture wicking aids in evaporative cooling.
- Insulation: Middle layers trap air, providing insulation against cold temperatures. The thickness and type of fabric determine the level of insulation. Multiple thinner insulating layers offer more flexibility than a single bulky one.
- Protection (Outer Layer): The outermost layer shields against the elements (wind, rain, snow) and should also be an FR garment providing the necessary arc rating or flame resistance for the specific hazard.
Crucially, every layer worn must be flame-resistant to ensure the entire clothing system provides the intended protection. Non-FR garments worn underneath can melt or ignite in a thermal event, exacerbating injuries.
Layering for Different Temperatures
The specific layering strategy will depend heavily on the ambient temperature and the level of physical exertion involved in the work.
Cold Environments
In cold weather, the primary goal is to retain body heat while maintaining FR protection. A typical cold-weather FR layering system might include:
- Base Layer: A lightweight FR moisture-wicking fabric (e.g., FR polyester or modacrylic blend).
- Insulating Layer(s): One or more layers of FR fleece or quilted FR fabric for warmth. The number and thickness of these layers can be adjusted based on the temperature.
- Outer Layer: A heavier FR jacket or parka that is windproof and potentially water-resistant.
Moderate Environments
In moderate temperatures, the focus shifts to comfort and maintaining FR protection without overheating. Layering options could include:
- Base Layer: An FR moisture-wicking shirt.
- Outer Layer: A lightweight FR work shirt or jacket. Additional insulating layers can be added if temperatures drop.
Hot Environments
Layering in hot environments might seem counterintuitive, but it can still be beneficial for moisture management and protection from radiant heat. The key is to choose lightweight, breathable FR fabrics:
- Base Layer: A lightweight, FR moisture-wicking shirt.
- Outer Layer: A lightweight FR work shirt or coverall.
Important Note: Avoid wearing unnecessary layers in hot environments to prevent heat stress. Focus on breathable FR fabrics that facilitate moisture evaporation.
Layering Strategies for Various Work Environments
Here are some specific examples of FR layering strategies for different work scenarios:
- Outdoor Cold Weather Electrical Work: FR moisture-wicking base layer, FR fleece mid-layer, FR insulated and water-resistant outer jacket, FR balaclava, and FR gloves.
- Indoor Hot Process (e.g., near furnaces): Lightweight FR moisture-wicking base layer and a lightweight, breathable FR coverall. Focus on staying hydrated and taking breaks in cooler areas.
- General Industrial Work in Moderate Climate: FR work shirt and FR pants. An FR vest or light jacket can be added if needed for changing temperatures.
Testing Your Layering Strategy
When layering flame-resistant (FR) clothing for enhanced protection, it's crucial to understand that you cannot simply add the individual arc ratings of each garment together. Instead, the specific combination of clothing must be tested together to determine the effective arc rating. This is because layering creates an insulating air gap between the garments, which significantly enhances protection by slowing heat transfer, often resulting in a combined rating far greater than the sum of its parts.
A significant challenge arises when workers use garments from different manufacturers, as there is often no universal standard for testing these varied combinations. Fabric mills and clothing companies typically test layering systems using only their own products, creating a gap in data for mixed-brand ensembles. This lack of available, verified data means employers and safety professionals must be diligent, either by requesting specific test reports or by standardizing their FR clothing programs to ensure that all worn combinations have a documented arc rating. Failing to do so can lead to a false sense of security and potentially catastrophic consequences in the event of an arc flash.
Regarding Moisture-Wicking Fabrics
While many consider moisture-wicking fabrics a modern invention, their history traces back to civilizations that recognized the importance of managing moisture against the skin, long before synthetic fibers existed. Today, this concept has evolved dramatically with advanced materials, and not all moisture-wicking properties are created equal.
Some garments are made from fibers that are inherently moisture-wicking, meaning their hydrophobic nature is a permanent part of the material's molecular structure, so they're guaranteed to retain their properties for the life of the garment. Think of it like a duck's feathers—they naturally repel water. In contrast, other fabrics are treated with a topical finish that, over time and repeated laundering, will wash out. These finishes essentially create a temporary hydrophobic surface. For optimal performance, the best FR base layers use a blend of fibers. They combine hydrophilic fibers, which love and absorb water like a sponge, with hydrophobic fibers. This pairing creates a powerful system: the hydrophilic fibers quickly pick up sweat from your skin, while the hydrophobic fibers transport or "wick" it away to the outer surface of the fabric, where it can evaporate. This blend ensures both rapid moisture pickup and efficient transport, keeping you dry and comfortable.
The percentage of blend of these two fibers is ultimately what determines the best comfort to performance ratio. The general consensus seems to be that if the numbers are roughly equal, performance is closer to optimal. Less hydrophilic fiber means less absorption, while less hydrophobic will not as effectively direct moisture away. Fabrics that use differing percentages of these fibers are typically labeled as ‘High Performance' by manufacturers — however; that difference in the fiber blending means that each fabric will perform differently. Always check the labels, or check directly with manufacturers to determine precisely what it is that you are buying. Your life may depend on it!
Key Considerations and Best Practices
- Always prioritize FR-rated garments for every layer. Non-FR clothing poses a significant safety risk.
- Consider the arc rating (if applicable). Ensure all layers collectively meet or exceed the required arc rating for the specific task.
- Moisture management is crucial for comfort and safety. Invest in FR moisture-wicking base layers.
- Avoid overly tight layers that can restrict movement or impede moisture evaporation.
- Inspect all FR garments regularly for damage or wear that could compromise their protective properties.
- Follow your company's specific safety guidelines and hazard assessments. These will provide the most accurate recommendations for FR clothing in your workplace.
- Consult with FR clothing manufacturers for guidance on specific layering systems and the compatibility and composition of different FR fabrics.
Conclusion
By understanding the principles of FR layering and considering the specific demands of your work environment, you can optimize both your safety and comfort while on the job. Remember that proper layering is an essential aspect of a comprehensive FR protection program. Always prioritize safety, adhere to relevant standards, and consult with safety professionals to ensure you are adequately protected.
For more comprehensive information on Arc-Rated and FR Clothing, including garment selection & care, garment layering, FR optimization in diverse environments, and other related topics please CLICK HERE.
goSafe offers a wide variety of Arc Flash Clothing and Equipment, as well as a complete line of customizable FR clothing and gear. We also maintain a constant, ready-to-ship supply of FR Clothing and Safety Footwear in our 'Core FR' department. For more information on these products or any of our other safety and PPE products, please contact us at sales@gosafe.com.
goSafe would like to thank Brad Sipe with Lakeland for his assistance in the production of this article.
goSafe: Your Partner in Safety
At goSafe, Safety is our ONLY focus - and we'll partner with you to keep you and your teams safe. We're small enough to handle your local projects, yet large enough to serve national accounts. If safety is your mission, it starts with us.
Watch the video below for more information about goSafe's capabilities.
