For decades, ladder cages were a common sight on fixed ladders, offering what many perceived as a layer of safety for workers at height. The idea was simple: if you slipped, the cage would keep you close to the ladder, preventing a catastrophic fall to the ground. However, modern safety standards and a deeper understanding of fall dynamics have revealed that ladder cages can often do more harm than good. It's time to understand why these seemingly protective enclosures are being phased out in favor of far superior alternatives.
While a cage might seem to offer a "catch," a fall within its confines can be incredibly dangerous and lead to severe injuries. Consider these inherent risks:
Impact Trauma: If a worker loses their footing and falls within a cage, they can collide violently with the rungs, the cage itself, or even the ground below. This can result in:
Entrapment and Asphyxiation: In a worst-case scenario, a falling worker can become entangled within the cage, leading to strangulation if their neck is caught, or asphyxiation if their breathing is restricted. Imagine a worker falling unconscious and becoming wedged; rescue becomes a complex and time-sensitive operation.
Difficult Rescues: When a worker falls within a cage, their position can make rescue extremely challenging. Emergency services may struggle to access the victim, prolonging the time before medical attention can be administered, which is critical in severe injury cases.
False Sense of Security: The presence of a cage can create a false sense of security, leading workers to be less vigilant about maintaining three points of contact or taking other necessary precautions. This overconfidence can ironically increase the risk of a fall.
One documented incident involved a worker descending a fixed cage ladder who lost his footing and fell 10 feet, fracturing both ankles. In another, a worker misjudged his position, leaning back where the cage no longer existed (cages typically end 7-8 feet from the ground), and fell over a railing, suffering fatal injuries. These examples highlight that cages do not reliably prevent severe injury or death during a fall.
The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) has recognized the limitations of ladder cages and updated its standards to promote more effective fall protection. Historically, cages were an acceptable form of fall protection for fixed ladders. However, this has changed. Below is a list showing how to be OSHA compliant when it comes to fixed ladders:
Under OSHA 29 CFR 1910.28(b)(9), for fixed ladders that extend more than 24 feet above a lower level:
This regulatory shift underscores a commitment to proactive fall prevention rather than relying on systems that may exacerbate injuries.
Thankfully, advanced fall protection systems offer significantly better safety for workers on fixed ladders. These are relatively simple, safe, alternatives to ladder cages that ensure long-term OSHA compliance:
A PFAS is a complete system designed to safely stop a worker's fall, limiting the force on their body and preventing them from hitting a lower level. Key components include:
Example: A worker climbing a tower might use a PFAS with a twin-leg shock absorbing lanyard. As they ascend, they attach one leg above them, then detach the leg below and continue upward in this manner. If a fall occurs, the lanyard engages and arrests the fall.
These systems are specifically designed for fixed ladders and offer continuous fall protection. They typically involve:
Example: A ladder leading to a rooftop might have a ladder safety system with a rigid rail. The worker clips their harness into a trolley on the rail. If they lose their grip, the trolley instantly engages, preventing a fall down the ladder.
The evolution of safety standards and technology has shown that ladder cages, while seemingly protective, are outdated and can be dangerous. The shift towards Personal Fall Arrest Systems and Ladder Safety Systems reflects a proactive approach to worker safety, minimizing the risk of severe injury and fatality from falls. Employers who prioritize worker well-being are not just meeting regulatory requirements; they are investing in a safer, more productive work environment by adopting modern, effective fall protection solutions.
For more comprehensive information on this topic, please visit CLICK HERE.
goSafe offers a variety of Ladder Safety Systems designed to ensure the safety of anyone climbing a fixed ladder. Ladder Stanchion Systems are available in multiple materials and configurations, as standalone stanchions or as complete systems including an SRL. Ladder Davits with a Mechanical Lift make traversing fixed ladders through a ceiling hatch safe and easy. For more information on these systems and other Fall Protection equipment from Reliance, contact us at sales@gosafe.com
At goSafe, Safety is our ONLY focus - and we'll partner with you to keep you and your teams safe. We're small enough to handle your local projects, yet large enough to serve national accounts. If safety is your mission, it starts with us.
Watch the video below for more information about goSafe's capabilities.
Are you on the lookout for more information on fall protection use? Visit our FAQ page today! There, you’ll find some bonus tips to help get you started.