The False Alarm Dilemma: Understanding and Mitigating Gas Detector Cross-Sensitivity

Gas detection systems are essential guardians in industrial settings, protecting people and assets from invisible hazards. However, a common and vexing issue known as cross-sensitivity can undermine their reliability, leading to frequent false alarms and a dangerous complacency known as 'alarm fatigue'. Understanding this phenomenon is the first step toward maintaining system integrity and workplace safety.

What is Gas Detector Cross-Sensitivity?

Cross-sensitivity occurs when a gas detector reacts to a non-target gas because the interfering gas possesses a similar chemical or physical property to the one the sensor is designed to detect.

• The Mimicry: Most common industrial gas sensors, particularly electrochemical and catalytic types, function by initiating a chemical reaction or physical change in the presence of the target gas. Cross-sensitivity happens when the interfering gas mimics this reaction or change. The sensor reads this 'mimic' signal and reports it as the target gas concentration, often triggering an alarm.

This isn't a sensor malfunction; it's a limitation based on the underlying detection technology. For instance, a sensor designed to oxidize a specific molecule may also oxidize a different, structurally similar molecule, resulting in an incorrect reading.

The Peril of Alarm Fatigue

False alarms aren't just an inconvenience—they pose a significant safety risk by introducing alarm fatigue.

• The Cycle: When safety personnel are bombarded with frequent, non-hazardous alarms caused by cross-sensitivity, they start to lose faith in the system. The natural response to a constantly beeping device is to silence or ignore it.
• The Danger: The true danger lies in the very real possibility that a genuine, life-threatening leak (a true threat) will occur during a period of high false alarms. Due to the preceding noise, personnel may delay their response, assume the alarm is 'just another false one,' or even bypass safety protocols altogether. This delay can have catastrophic consequences.

Common Examples of Cross-Sensitivity

Cross-sensitivity is a practical concern across various detection technologies. Here are a couple of notable examples:

• Carbon Monoxide (CO) Sensors and Hydrogen (H₂): CO sensors are vital for detecting the colorless, odorless byproduct of incomplete combustion. However, many standard CO electrochemical sensors will also react significantly to Hydrogen (H₂) gas. Since H₂ is a common industrial component, fuel cell reactant, and even a natural byproduct in some processes, its presence can trigger an unnecessary CO alarm, even at safe CO levels.
• Flammable Gas Sensors (LEL) and Siloxanes: Catalytic bead (pellistor) sensors, used to detect flammable gases (like methane or propane) in the Lower Explosive Limit (LEL) range, can suffer from sensor poisoning. While technically a different issue, the reaction to chemicals like siloxanes (found in some sealants and cleaning products) can permanently degrade the sensor's sensitivity, effectively rendering it useless or causing a persistently low, false reading when no gas is present.

Mitigating Cross-Sensitivity and Restoring System Integrity

Fortunately, manufacturers and safety engineers have developed effective strategies to minimize false alarms without compromising detection capabilities.

1. Consult the Manufacturer’s Cross-Sensitivity Chart

This is arguably the single most important step. Every reputable gas detector manufacturer provides a cross-sensitivity chart or table for each sensor type.

• How to Read It: The chart lists various common interfering gases and provides a correction factor or a percentage sensitivity relative to the target gas.
  • Example: If a CO sensor chart shows a 50% sensitivity to H₂, it means a concentration of 100 ppm of H₂ will cause the sensor to read an equivalent of 50 ppm of CO.
• Actionable Data: By comparing the chart data with the known background gases in your environment, you can understand the potential for false alarms and adjust alarm thresholds or select a more appropriate sensor technology.

2. Utilize Selective Filters and Compensated Sensors 

The most effective modern solution is the use of specialized chemical filters integrated directly into the sensor head.

• CO Sensor with an H₂ Filter: To solve the common CO/H₂ cross-sensitivity issue, manufacturers offer CO sensors with an integrated Hydrogen-blocking filter. This chemical filter selectively removes or significantly reduces the H₂ molecules reaching the sensing electrode without impacting the CO molecules, dramatically improving accuracy.
• H₂S Sensor with a Filter: Similarly, filters can be used to mitigate the effects of gases like Sulfur Dioxide (SO₂) on Hydrogen Sulfide (H₂S) sensors, which are critical for detecting highly toxic H₂S gas.

3. Implement Sensor Diversity

In areas with complex gas mixtures, consider using different detection technologies that have complementary strengths and weaknesses.

• For flammable gas detection, using both a catalytic pellistor (good LEL range, but prone to poisoning) and an infrared (IR) sensor (immune to poisoning and high accuracy, but may not detect H₂) provides redundancy and allows for comparison between readings, validating true threats.

Conclusion

By proactively addressing the false alarm dilemma through careful sensor selection, the use of filters, and a thorough review of cross-sensitivity data, facilities can ensure their gas detection systems remain a trustworthy line of defense against atmospheric hazards.

goSafe offers a wide variety of Instrumentation suitable for every task related to gas detection. goSafe also offers and Instrumentation Management program. We can help keep your monitors working properly with warranty, repair, calibration, and recertification services. We'll even handle inventory and shipping. Contact Us for more information or for any questions related to safety and safety-related products.

For more information about Instrumentation, including Sensor Drift and Degradation, Calibration Issues, Cross Sensitivity Issues, Sensor Poisoning and Inhibition, Proper and Improper Installation and Placement, Power Supply and Connectivity Problems, and Routine Maintenance and Training, please Click Here.

goSafe: Your Partner in Safety

At goSafe, Safety is our ONLY focus - and we'll partner with you to keep you and your teams safe. We're small enough to handle your local projects, yet large enough to serve national accounts. If safety is your mission, it starts with us.

Watch the video below for more information about goSafe's capabilities.