Working at height on fixed ladders is an inherent part of many industries, from industrial plants to telecommunications and utilities. Ensuring the safety of workers ascending and descending these ladders is paramount, and two primary fall protection systems dominate the landscape: traditional/fixed engineered vertical climbing systems and vertical ladder stanchion systems. Each offers distinct advantages and disadvantages, and understanding these can help you make the best choice for your specific needs.
These systems are often what comes to mind when you think of ladder safety. They typically involve a permanently installed rail or cable running the length of the ladder, to which a worker's personal fall arrest system (PFAS) connects via a trolley or shuttle.
Pros:
Continuous Fall Protection: Once connected, the worker has continuous fall protection along the entire climb. There's no need to disconnect and re-connect at different points.
Ease of Use (Once Engaged): For a single, continuous climb, these systems are relatively straightforward for workers to use once they've attached to the system.
Less Reliance on User Technique: The system itself guides the fall arrest device, reducing the chance of user error during the climb compared to some alternative methods.
Suitable for High Frequency Use: For ladders that are accessed very frequently by multiple users, the integrated nature of these systems can be efficient.
Compliance with Standards: Well-designed and installed systems readily meet OSHA and ANSI standards for vertical fall protection.
Cons:
Higher Initial Installation Cost: Installing a full-length rail or cable system can be labor-intensive and require outside installers, leading to a higher upfront investment.
Permanent Fixture/Aesthetics: The system is a permanent fixture on the ladder, which may be a consideration for aesthetic reasons or if the ladder's use might change in the future.
Potential for Obstruction: The rail or cable can sometimes slightly obstruct the ladder rungs or make carrying larger tools more cumbersome, though this is often minimal.
Maintenance: While generally low, the system still requires periodic inspection and maintenance to ensure the integrity of the rail/cable and connections.
Ladder Modifications: Installation often requires drilling into or clamping onto the existing ladder structure, which needs to be carefully considered for structural integrity.
Vertical ladder stanchion systems represent a different approach. Instead of a continuous rail, these systems typically involve attachment of a robust stanchion that acts as an anchor point at the top of the ladder. Workers use a self-retracting lifeline (SRL) that is connected to this stanchion as they ascend.
Pros:
Lower Initial Cost (Potentially): For certain applications, particularly where ladders are less frequently accessed or are part of a larger fall protection plan involving personal equipment, the initial cost of installing stanchions can be lower than a full rail system.
Less Restrictive Movement for Users: SRLs are attached to a user's full body harness via the dorsal D-ring. This attachment point; as opposed to the attachment point on the chest for an engineered system, offers less restrictive, greater freedom of movement in most scenarios scenarios.
Minimal Ladder Modification: Installation involves less intrusive modifications to the ladder itself compared to a continuous rail system.
Reduced Visual Impact: Stanchions are less visually prominent than a full-length rail, which might be a consideration in some architectural or public-facing environments.
Easier Repair/Replacement: If a stanchion is damaged, it's often easier and less disruptive to repair or replace than a section of a continuous rail system.
Cons:
Greater Reliance on User Technique: Workers need to be diligently trained in proper connection, disconnection, and re-connection procedures when both connecting to and disconnecting from the system, increasing the potential for user error if not adequately followed.
Complexity with Multiple Users: Managing multiple users on the same ladder with stanchion systems can be more complex, as each worker needs their own connection points. As only one person can be attached to an SRL at a time, this can increase the amount of time it takes to get all users from point A to point B.
Anchor Point Availability: The effectiveness of the system depends on the appropriateness of the ladder itself to act as an anchor point for the SRL when the stanchion is attached. A qualified person will have to determine if the ladder is in fact appropriate for use in this manner.
The choice between a traditional/fixed engineered vertical climbing system and a vertical ladder stanchion system depends on several factors:
Frequency of Use: For high-traffic ladders, a continuous system often provides greater efficiency and safety. For infrequently accessed ladders, stanchions might be a more cost-effective solution.
Number of Users: Multi-user scenarios generally favor continuous systems for ease of management and inherent safety.
Budget: Initial installation costs can be a significant factor.
Ladder Configuration: The design and structural integrity of your existing ladders will influence what can be installed.
Worker Training and Experience: The level of training and experience of your workforce can impact the choice, especially concerning systems requiring more active user engagement.
Specific Industry Regulations: Always consult relevant OSHA, ANSI, and local regulations to ensure compliance.
Risk Assessment: A thorough risk assessment of your specific work environment and ladder use is crucial in determining the most appropriate and safest fall protection solution.
Ultimately, both traditional engineered systems and stanchion systems can provide effective fall protection on fixed ladders when properly designed, installed, and used. A careful evaluation of your unique circumstances and a commitment to comprehensive worker training will guide you toward the safest and most efficient choice for your operations.
For more comprehensive information on this topic, please visit CLICK HERE.
goSafe offers a variety of Ladder Safety Systems designed to ensure the safety of anyone climbing a fixed ladder. Ladder Stanchion Systems are available in multiple materials and configurations, as standalone stanchions or as complete systems including an SRL. Ladder Davits with a Mechanical Lift make traversing fixed ladders through a ceiling hatch safe and easy. For more information on these systems and other Fall Protection equipment from Reliance, contact us at sales@gosafe.com
At goSafe, Safety is our ONLY focus - and we'll partner with you to keep you and your teams safe. We're small enough to handle your local projects, yet large enough to serve national accounts. If safety is your mission, it starts with us.
Watch the video below for more information about goSafe's capabilities.
Are you on the lookout for more information on fall protection use? Visit our FAQ page today! There, you’ll find some bonus tips to help get you started.